Thanks for sharing this. I learned something :)

+1 for this unusual approach as an exception -- Georg Link (he/him)

I like the proposed new criteria for its simplicity and potential for automation in the future. I also like the optics of it. If that's the only criteria that's not met, then a badge is at ~99% (?). A

David, Thanks for diligently maintaining the CII Best Practices badge website. Best, Georg

This is fantastic news! Congratulations to the Linux Kernel. Thanks for highlighting this achievement. Georg

David, Thanks for the updated. This is great! Best, Georg

TL;DR: I agree. David Wheeler: That's fair. Let's not add to the problem. Okay, sure thing. I err on over communicating and even at home I get pushback :) Great. Happy to see the R Community embracing

Out of curiosity: How do we know how prevalent it is to use the badge app to lookup implementation languages? What other information do we know are many people looking for? Do we know what they are us

Thanks David, I acknowledge the technical challenge of my idea and agree that personalized emails for every project may not be feasible. How are badge creators usually notified of updates and changes

+1 I think this is a good idea. Could we 'stage' the change and send a notification email to the badge creators about the planned change to their entry? The badge creators can then add the correct lan

Whow! It's great to see this many new badge holders! Congratulations to all!

This is great news. Thanks for sharing! A few thoughts on the blog post. I throw them out here for comments. I is great to see that the value of the badge is perceived by so many, even if they have no

I was thinking of a tooltip for each of the percentages, not on the table title. When you hover over the value 250% the tooltip would show "silver + 50% towards gold". Mockery! -- Maybe it worked and

That makes sense. How about displaying the percentage and clarifying what it means in a mouse-over tooltip? Georg

The percentages as proposed are logical. Could we, instead of going above 100% (more than the whole), display current level plus percentage of next level? Here are examples with interpretation: * 95%

Sounds reasonable, thanks David.

Thanks David, It might be helpful to additionally document how long activity logs are kept and when they are either anonymized or deleted. Because the goal "to detect and fix erroneous behavior, as we